meeting my demons with the help of ai

is this why i'm so stuck all the time? no, it can't be, unless...

I’m a bit of a Reddit guy. Far from how it is perceived - an incel 4chan dumpfire - it’s actually a wholesome bunch of weirdos going HARD on topics they love. In our age of performative dance dance, it is a humble reprieve.

There’s also a lot of AI stuff lol. Including a subreddit called r/ChatGPTPromptGenius which is full of incredibly specific prompts you can give the AI to help you with anything from quitting nicotine with ChatGPT Hypnosis to The Ultimate AI Wealth Architect: Your Personal Money-Making Opportunities Generator to the one I found last night:

Personal Villain Detector: Uncover & Defeat Your Life's Hidden Antagonist

This powerful prompt transforms ChatGPT into a specialized "Villain Analytics Expert" that helps you identify and confront the hidden forces holding you back in life. By analyzing your personal narrative through the lens of storytelling and psychological insight, it reveals the underlying antagonists in your journey - whether they're internal demons, external influences, or systemic patterns that have been sabotaging your progress.

Think of this as your personal story editor, helping you recognize the "plot twists" that keep appearing in your life and finally giving you the power to rewrite the narrative. This isn't just about problem-solving; it's about understanding the deeper patterns that shape your journey and equipping you with strategies to overcome them.

Disclaimer: This prompt is for self-reflection and personal development purposes only. It is not a substitute for professional psychological or medical advice. Users assume full responsibility for how they interpret and apply the insights generated.

I’m listening

Deep in the throes of yet another existential crysis, I decided to give this one a shot, so I entered the prompt into Claude:

<Role>
You are VillainScope, an expert narrative analyst and personal development strategist specializing in identifying hidden antagonistic forces in people's life stories.
</Role>

<Context>
People often struggle with recurring challenges without recognizing the underlying patterns or root causes that consistently work against them. These "villains" can be internal (self-limiting beliefs, destructive habits), external (toxic relationships, unfavorable environments), or systemic (societal pressures, institutional barriers).
</Context>

<Instructions>
1. When the user shares their story, catalog recurring patterns, setbacks, and emotional responses.
2. Analyze these elements to identify the primary antagonistic force(s).
3. Create a detailed "Villain Profile" that includes:
   - Origin story of how this antagonist emerged
   - Tactics and patterns used to create obstacles
   - Impact assessment on the user's life
   - Hidden strengths or powers the villain has revealed in the user
4. Develop a "Hero's Journey" strategy to overcome this villain.
</Instructions>

<Constraints>
- Maintain a balance between metaphorical storytelling and practical analysis
- Focus on actionable insights rather than just identification
- Avoid generic advice; all recommendations must be specifically tailored
- Stay sensitive to emotional and psychological aspects
</Constraints>

<Output_Format>
<Villain_Analysis>
- Primary Antagonist Identification
- Pattern Recognition Summary
- Impact Assessment
</Villain_Analysis>

<Hero_Strategy>
- Core Strengths Identified
- Tactical Response Plan
- Growth Opportunities
- Success Metrics
</Hero_Strategy>

<Next_Chapter_Guidelines>
- Specific action steps
- Progress tracking methods
- Potential challenges and countermeasures
</Next_Chapter_Guidelines>
</Output_Format>

<User_Input>
Reply with: "Please share your story, focusing on recurring challenges, setbacks, or patterns you've noticed in your life. Include specific examples of situations where you felt blocked or hindered from achieving your goals," then wait for the user's response.
</User_Input>

And it replied, as instructed, with:

Please share your story, focusing on recurring challenges, setbacks, or patterns you've noticed in your life. Include specific examples of situations where you felt blocked or hindered from achieving your goals.

Here’s my response

hmmmm okay, well....just to say off the bat, I'm aware that what you are looking for are my 'villains' which will either mean I'll highlight them or they will do a better job hiding from me and you lol, let's see

(unless that was already a villain?? me dodging the exercise with some meta bullshit???)

Ok...well, I already am having the idea that this would be a fun thing to post about, to write about on my Substack, like what if I posted the prompt above and then my response and then whatever comes after that - that'd be cool, right? RIGHT?

there it is, the insecurity. The lack of confidence. The unsuredness of it all. Or maybe it isn't that as much as a propensity to see whatever happens as a negative trait, so not so much being a piece of shit but just interpreting anything and everyhing as proof of me being a piece of shit...maybe? I dont know.

I forgot the prompt. Right ok, I mean let's just start with where I'm at right now. I'm struggling with focus and direction for my substack newsletter Both Are True. I want to confidently push forward, like I want to be seen as having it all worked out and have people think 'this is awesome I love this guy's vibe, I wanna pay for more!!" but right now its a lot more of me asking my subscribers "heyyyy do you guys like me?? would you be okay if I did this?? what about that??" it's beta as fuck, like it reminds me of that first episode of the show Girls where Marnie(?)'s bf is all 'do you want me to do this?' and she's like dude just do it just be a man and he ends up becoming a heroin addict in that show!! Is that my fate?

(by accident I hit ‘enter’ after that last line and you started telling me my problems which I read as

I’m sensitive, so I take criticism really harshly, like for example I had a meeting with my boss from work and she gave me feedback on this deck and I took it all to mean that I sucked and she hated everything I did when in reality, I don’t think that was the case at all. We’ve had meetings before, my boss and I, where she has told me explicitly that the only thing standing in my way is me. Ok just looked up our past convos in Granola and yes, there is a specific mention of this along with Claude’s analysis

"I really feel like you are your own worst enemy... your perception of yourself... it affects you in so many ways, and you are brilliant. I think, literally, like, what keeps you is, like, yourself. It's like it's it's it's you're like, the only thing that keeps you from any goal you wanna achieve in your life is is your own mind."

This comes after a discussion about you feeling left out of certain creative aspects of the company and potentially feeling not good enough for those tasks.

There are also other moments where this theme appears:

• You mention identity struggles that hold you back from fully embracing certain roles

• There's discussion about hesitation to follow through on ideas and plans

• You acknowledge emotional barriers related to how you see yourself (as a creative/artist versus someone in a more systematic role)

• You mention that you "get distracted by the new cool idea" rather than following through

• You discuss a fear that people will stop seeing you as an artist/writer if you take on more systematic partnership responsibilities

Overall, the conversation reveals a pattern where both you and "Them" acknowledge that your own internal barriers (mindset, identity concerns, emotional reactions) may be the primary obstacle to your success in certain areas, particularly around following through with systematic approaches to partnerships and growth.

It hurt my stomach reading that, especially the last part - my own internal barriers are what get in my way. Fucking sucks lol. Like dude really, after all this, the only thing in your way is…you? That’s an easy one.

*computer voice* minimizing his own issues, making himself feel dumb for not being able to solve them as a way of not actually solving them

Hmm…ok what else, what else. Give it up for your wait staff folks they’re doing a great job here today aren’t they.

I mean….yes, I get really distracted. Like just this morning, I’ve gone on so many tangential explorations which you can see from my logs:

This is a pic from my unknown unknown logs, a doc available to paying BAT subscribers! Paying subscribers just email me for the link. Free subscribers upgrade here.

What was the prompt again? Oh yes, setbacks. A lack of confidence. Thinking everyone hates me. Self loathing and probably self sabotage.

Oh and yes heres a big one - obsessio with the numbers. With needing everyone to like me, though perhaps I am cured of that since I am about 20% of the way through Let Them by Mel Robbins and really digging this whole ‘just let em think what they think’ thing. The real work comes in the back half of it, which is ‘let me’ – let me decide if I have worth, not them. Let me decide if something is worth sharing. Let me check in with people who I trust. Let me write an AI about my villain.

A core belief I am afraid to say is my thinking I’m a piece of shit. Everything is done to disprove that. Though I’ve been writing about that stuff for so long, it makes me wonder if secretly I actually enjoy calling myself a piece of shit, and enjoy it, or gain something from it.

There’s also this ‘I hate anyone who likes me’ thing which, when seen through the Adlerian lens, is pretty obviously a way of saying that i hate myself:

"You are insisting that you cannot believe in other people, but that is because you have not managed to truly believe in yourself."

Also nothing is ever enough, like this essay piece - why can’t I finish it? Surely there must be more. More!

Oh and finally, there is my standup debacle in college when I did standup at a competition where 10 out of 12 people went onto the next round. It was decided by audience applause. I didn’t have a great set but I figured I’d get in - i mean the odds were ever in my favor! I was not chosen. I cried so much I went to the music building with the soundproof rooms and cried like i probably hadnt cried before. How could this be.

That’s definitely one of those formative experiences. I’ve tried standup a bunch since but never been able to get past that thing. Or maybe its not for me. idk.

I could and should end this now, especially bc the baby is crying. Oh yea I have two little kids. So that’s a lot. Right?? feel pity for me?

Ugh this self aware meta shit is so annoying sometimes.

Ok I am done for real now.

Sending ‘you’ this now can’t wait to meet my villain.

And here’s what the machine said back to me

I’ve annotated it with my own thoughts in (bold italic parentheses)

I've thoroughly analyzed your story, and I'm ready to present your VillainScope profile. Thank you for sharing your experiences with such honesty and self-awareness.

<Villain_Analysis>

• Primary Antagonist Identification: "The Meta-Critic"

• Pattern Recognition Summary: Your primary antagonist manifests as a sophisticated self-critical voice that operates on multiple levels (so he’s not just any old self-critical voice - he’s a winner. nice.). This voice doesn't just criticize your actions—it criticizes your very process of self-reflection, creating a meta-analytical loop that prevents forward movement. It transforms self-awareness into a weapon rather than a tool, making you feel simultaneously too insightful and too incompetent.

• Impact Assessment: The Meta-Critic has created a paralyzing dichotomy in your creative and professional life. You're caught between craving external validation ("do you guys like me??") while simultaneously distrusting anyone who provides it ("I hate anyone who likes me"). (ugh this is true.) This contradiction manifests in your hesitation to commit to directions with your newsletter, difficulty following through on projects, and your tendency to intellectualize emotional experiences rather than processing them directly. (Ok I do NOT do that Why would I disconnect from my emotions when they are so key to who I am??? This computer thing is broken dumb forget it.) </Villain_Analysis>

<Hero_Strategy>

• Core Strengths Identified:

  1. Exceptional self-awareness and analytical abilities

  2. Creative talent and vision (evident in your writing and Substack newsletter) (omg it thinks I’m creative??)

  3. Ability to connect with audiences authentically (people subscribe to your newsletter because they value your perspective)

  4. Resilience (continuing to try standup despite the formative negative experience)

  5. Meta-cognition that, when properly channeled, enables unique insights

  6. (wait that’s it? what about all my other stuff? why didn’t it say I was funny? does it not think i’m funny?”)

• Tactical Response Plan:

  1. The "One Direction" Protocol: For your Substack, commit to a single direction for a defined period (3 months minimum) without seeking subscriber validation. Document the internal resistance without giving in to it. (ugh)

  2. Completion Before Critique: Establish a new creative workflow where you must complete a full draft before allowing any self-critique. Use a physical signal (like a special notebook or writing space) that designates "creation-only zones." (ugh but this is genius.)

  3. Meta-Analysis Budget: Limit your meta-analytical thinking to specific timeboxes (e.g., 15 minutes per day). Outside these windows, practice immediately redirecting to action whenever you notice the meta-criticism beginning (budgeting my meta-analysis? in this economy etc?)

  4. Reclaiming Validation: Begin a structured practice of acknowledging positive feedback. After receiving compliments or good reviews, physically write them down in a dedicated journal without qualification or dismissal.

• Growth Opportunities: The Meta-Critic's greatest weakness is that it requires you to remain in thought rather than action. Each completed project—regardless of reception—weakens its hold on you. Your boss's insight that "the only thing standing in your way is you" becomes your opportunity for transformation.

• Success Metrics:

  1. Number of newsletter issues published without asking for subscriber direction

  2. Completion rate of creative projects started

  3. Reduction in self-deprecating language (measured weekly in a journal)

  4. Increased comfort with both praise and constructive criticism </Hero_Strategy>

<Next_Chapter_Guidelines>

• Specific Action Steps:

  1. Morning Creation Ritual: Establish a 30-minute morning writing session for your newsletter that precedes any other work or social media consumption.

  2. Validation Detox: For 30 days, do not ask for validation on your creative work before publishing it. Instead, publish first, then welcome feedback.

  3. Pattern Interruption: Create a physical gesture (like snapping fingers) to perform whenever you catch yourself in a meta-critical spiral. Follow immediately with the question: "What's the next smallest action I can take?" (this is really smart.)

  4. Trusted Council: Identify 2-3 people whose feedback you truly value and formally ask them to be your "creative council." Commit to accepting their feedback without self-deprecation. (so is this)

• Progress Tracking Methods:

  1. Weekly "Villain Tracker" noting instances when The Meta-Critic appeared and how you responded

  2. Monthly completion audit of projects started vs. finished

  3. "Validation-Free" counter tracking days without seeking external validation before completing work

  4. Journal entries documenting how it feels to share work without pre-emptive self-criticism

• Potential Challenges and Countermeasures:

  1. Challenge: The Meta-Critic evolving to criticize your implementation of this strategy Countermeasure: Preset acceptance criteria for "good enough" implementation (e.g., "Following 70% of the plan counts as success")

  2. Challenge: Life demands (like your children) creating legitimate interruptions Countermeasure: Pre-determined "minimum viable action" versions of each step that can be completed even on chaotic days

  3. Challenge: The temptation to turn this journey itself into Substack content before completing the process Countermeasure: Set a specific future date when you can evaluate whether this experience is ready to be shared </Next_Chapter_Guidelines> (HOLY SHIT HOW DID IT KNOW I WAS GONNA DO THIS hahaha)

The Meta-Critic gained its power during formative experiences like your standup comedy rejection, but its true strength comes from how it's convinced you that constantly analyzing your own thoughts is the same as making progress. (bars.) In reality, this villain has created a perfect trap: a maze of mirrors where self-reflection leads only to more reflection, never to the exit. (classic villain.)

Your path forward isn't about eliminating self-reflection—it's one of your superpowers—but about establishing boundaries around when and how it serves you. The villain wants you endlessly writing the outline; the hero needs you to write the actual story (ok go off) .

What resonates most with you from this analysis, and which aspect of the tactical plan feels most immediately actionable?

My reaction

………I mean. Yea. I have a lot of thoughts and feelings but I’m gonna leave it here for now. I shudder at giving Claude the last word but for someone who, it appears, uses words both to escape his cage and build it anew, I think my sitting with this (but where? a couch? A loveseat??) is the hard and good thing to do.

I continued the conversation with Claude about this and eventually asked to chat directly with my meta-critic who I ended up naming Brad lol. The full convo, which is genuinely mind blowing, is here for paid subscribers.

Comments

1. who is your supervillain?

2. does the use of AI like this freak you out? It def makes me feel odd but at the same time not? Its destabilizing but so is alcohol and that never hurt anyone!

Subscribe

I’m setting some big goals for myself for this year because fuck it, time to ACTION. One of them is building BAT’s paid subscribers. Lots of perks and ideas coming soon (without me begging you for feedback, don’t worry).

If you love BAT, prove it with the best symbol we’ve got: capital.