43 Comments
User's avatar
Monia Ali's avatar

This is making me rethink my approach and I don't know what to do! I tend to use notes when I don't have enough to say in a post and I don't want to "bother" subscribers with something less thought out, but maybe I should be reaching out to those that have actually signed up for my ramblings instead or reaching into the void. Much food for thought, thank you.

(Despite the substack claim that followers increase subscribers, that has not been the case for me, so my reliance on notes may be incredibly stupid.)

Expand full comment
山伏 (Yamabushi)'s avatar

Why not ask your readers if they would appreciate the odd short post? I bet most of them don't see your notes at all.

Expand full comment
Monia Ali's avatar

I might do that in one that I'm working on now (a short one, with more audience sourcing).

I think I've seen the drop in subs from "bad" posts which has made me more self conscious about sending out things. Then again, my deeply researched and sourced content does much worse than my off -the-cuff rants!

Expand full comment
Myq Kaplan's avatar

dear alex,

this is a beautiful song:

"I just met you

And this is crazy

But I’m a writer

So pay me maybe"

thank you and love you!

myq

Expand full comment
Charlie Lentine's avatar

But did you pay him…

Expand full comment
Myq Kaplan's avatar

maybe!

Expand full comment
Michael Estrin's avatar

I double checked your math, Alex. The math does indeed math.

Expand full comment
Jeannine Lawall's avatar

I try to stay out of the Notes - I know me, I would get sucked right in and, whoosh, one, two, three hours would be gone, just like that, no idea where they went. Lack of executive function can be a dangerous thing, but after 60+ decades I've learned to avoid things that I know will be detrimental to my small pool of "extra" (stolen?) time.

Expand full comment
Mark McGuire's avatar

Definitely agree. No notes for me. Not even going close. Not now. Not ever. Not since Twitter when it was Twitter and Instagram before it had ads and not until the cows come back to their home page. I know better than that. You bet I do. I’m not even here, if you ask me.

Expand full comment
Louise with Leader for Good's avatar

"The cool people are not there. The cool people – the actually cool people – are not on social media. They are free. They escaped, and they can’t tell us how, for doing so would render their escape null and bring them back to the void."

Love this! Reminds me of an article Ryan Holiday wrote: The most successful people are the ones you've never heard of.

Expand full comment
Heather Hoskison's avatar

The "illusion of free will"

Expand full comment
Eduardo de Leon's avatar

Thank you! I only comment here to get some attention, so please like this comment. Maybe Notes would be more adequate? But, then l‘d have to come up with own stuff. I’m not able to create such elaborate statistical analysis and visualize it as well as you did here. Now I have an urge to prompt Leonardo AI with “Dandy Lions”.

Expand full comment
Fantasma.'s avatar

The visuals were helpful. I found myself finding the useful.

Expand full comment
Michael Jensen's avatar

Now I don't feel so bad about failing so much with Notes...

Expand full comment
Ginny Poe's avatar

Yeah, notes kinda bums me out cos I thought I had taken strides to not be hooked on SM and yet here I am

Expand full comment
Dani Oliveira's avatar

You know, maybe that's why I can never stick with these things (aka social media) 💭

Expand full comment
Mark McGuire's avatar

I’d love to stay and chat, but I’ve got journeys to start, moments to savour, roses to smell, and little things to enjoy. But, hey, whatever turns your wheel, as hamsters say.

Expand full comment
Nico Sakaki's avatar

"No matter what, just be like a train and choo choo choose (it’s sentences like this that I’m being told are keeping me from a Nobel Laureate)."

Those people are wrong. Actually, they're probably right, but only because the way we determine what gets to be considered Very Important Literature is deeply flawed.

I am going to add this to my collection of favourite random sentences.

Expand full comment
Ororo Munroe's avatar

Not only would I love to see a forest full of dandy lions, but I would also love to see a forest of dandelions. But also, my stance on Notes is "Notes? WTF are those?" BWAHA!

Expand full comment
G. K. Sá Earp's avatar

"Some real passive voice bullshit" needs to become a mainstream writing term.

Expand full comment
Salvador Lorca 📚 ⭕️'s avatar

only 2% of substackers writing on notes? Really?

Expand full comment